
Tony Lambert delphine1939@videotron.ca
5 Janvier 2007
Eating Disorders: Anorexia and Bulimia
March 2002
WHAT ARE EATING DISORDERS?
Eating disorders are devastating behavioral maladies brought on by a complex interplay of factors, which may include emotional and personality disorders, family pressures, a possible genetic or biologic susceptibility, and a culture in which there is an overabundance of food and an obsession with thinness. There are four general categories of eating disorders:
These are not new disorders. Although anorexia nervosa was first defined as a medical problem in the late 1800s, descriptions of self-starvation have been found even in medieval writings.
Bulimia Nervosa
Bulimia nervosa is more common than anorexia and it usually begins early in adolescence. It is characterized by cycles of bingeing and purging, and typically takes the following pattern:
It should be noted that young people who occasionally force vomiting after eating too much are not considered bulimic, and most of the time this occasional unhealthy behavior does not continue beyond youth.
Anorexia Nervosa
Anorexia nervosa involves an aversion to food that leads to a state of starvation and emaciation. Facts associated with anorexia nervosa include:
Patients with the condition are often characterized as anorexia restrictors or anorexic bulimic patients. Each type is about equally prevalent.
It should be noted that the term "anorexia" literally means absence of appetite. For example, severe anorexia is common in the elderly, who may experience weight loss because of social isolation, impaired gastrointestinal function, or loss of certain chemicals related to the feeding drive. Such anorexia, however, is not synonymous with anorexia nervosa, which is a psychologic disorder.
Binge-Eating (Binge-Eating Disorder)
Binge-eating without purging is characterized as compulsively overeating (binge eating) without other bulimic behaviors, such as vomiting or laxative abuse, used to eliminate calories. Binge-eating usually leads to becoming overweight.
To be diagnosed as a binge eater, a person typically has the following characteristics:
Since binge-eating disorder is generally associated with weight gain, it will not be further discussed in this report. [For more information on bingeing without purging, see the Well-Connected Report #53, Obesity.]
Eating Disorders Not Otherwise Specified
A fourth category called eating disorders not otherwise specified (NOS) has been established to define eating disorders not specifically defined as anorexia or bulimia. This category includes the following:
WHO DEVELOPS EATING DISORDERS?
The approach to food in Western Countries is extremely problematic. Enough food is produced in the US to supply 3,800 calories every day to each man, woman, and child, far more than any single person needs to sustain life. Obesity is a global epidemic, and few people living in this over-fed and sedentary culture eat a meal guiltlessly. One can nearly make the sweeping generalization that everyone who lives in a developed nation is at risk for either obesity or some eating disorder.
Age
In general, eating disorders occur in adolescents and young adults, although one study reported that 5% of cases occurred in children under 12 years old.
Age of Onset for Bulimia. A 1997 survey by the Centers for Disease Control of high school students reported that 4.5% induced vomiting after meals or used laxatives to lose weight. Estimates of the prevalence of bulimia nervosa among young women range from about 3% in adolescents to 10% in college women. Some experts claim that even these percentages grossly underestimate the problem because many people with bulimia are able to conceal their purging and do not become noticeably underweight. For example, a European study detected bulimic behavior in 14.4% of adolescents 14 to 16 years old, with full-blown bulimia observed in 1.8% of girls and 0.3% of boys.
Age of Onset for Anorexia Nervosa. Anorexia nervosa is the third most common chronic illness in adolescent women, and is estimated to occur in 0.5% to 3% of all teenagers. Anorexia usually first occurs in adolescence with peaks at 13 to 14 years of age and at 17 to 18 years of age. Over the past 40 years, however, the incidence has been steady in teenagers, but it has increased threefold in young adult women.
Gender
Studies typically report that 90% of eating disorder cases are in females. However, the rate in males appears to be increasing. For example, a 2000 study of teenagers in Minnesota reported that 13% of girls and 7% of boys reported disordered eating behavior.
When eating disorders occurs in young adults, men are more apt to conceal them, so the incidence among males may be underreported. One study of Navy men, for example, reported a prevalence of 2.5% for anorexia, 6.8% of bulimia, and 40% for binge eating. A 2001 study reported that the psychiatric and social profiles of men and women with eating disorders were very similar to each other, although profiles between men with eating disorders and men without were quite different. Sexual preference may affect the risk of specific eating disorders in men. One study reported that 42% of male civilians with bulimia reported that they were homosexual or bisexual while 58% of the men with anorexia were asexual.
Ethnic Factors
Most studies of individuals with eating disorders have been conducted using Caucasian middle-class females. Studies are now reporting, however, that minority populations, including Hispanic- and African-American, are significantly affected. There is some indication that African-American girls and young women may be at particular risk for eating disorders because of poor body images caused by cultural attitudes that denigrate the physical characteristics of minorities. In one study, bulimia was equally common among both Caucasian and African American women, although the latter were more likely to binge recurrently, to fast, and to use laxatives and diuretics to control weight. Binge eating may be an even more severe a problem in Hispanic Americans. A 2000 study on Asian women also reported rates of dieting and body dissatisfaction that were similar to those in other cultures, but Asian women had much lower percentages of actual eating disorders.
Socioeconomic Factors
Living in any economically developed nation on any continent appears to pose more of a risk for eating disorders than belonging to a particular population group. Symptoms remain strikingly similar across high-risk countries.
Income Levels. Oddly enough, within developed countries there appears to be no difference in risk between the rich and the poor. Some studies suggest that those in lower economic groups may be at higher risk for bulimia.
Urban Life. City living is a risk factor for bulimia but it has no effect on risk for anorexia.
Intelligence. In one sample, people with eating disorders scored significantly higher than average on IQ tests. People with bulimia, but not anorexia, had higher nonverbal than verbal scores.
Excessively Physically Active People
Highly competitive athletes are often perfectionists, a trait common among people with eating disorders.
Women Athletes and Dancers. Women in "appearance" sports, including gymnastics and figure skating, and in endurance sports, such as track and cross-country, are at particular risk for anorexia. Success in ballet also depends on the development of a wiry and extremely slim body. Estimates for episodes of eating disorders among such athletes and performers range from 15% to over 60%.
Male Athletes. Male wrestlers and light-weight rowers are also at risk for excessive dieting. One-third of high school wrestlers use a method called weight-cutting for rapid weight loss. This process involves food restriction and fluid depletion using steam rooms, saunas, laxatives, and diuretics. Although male athletes are more apt to resume normal eating patterns once competition ends, studies are showing that the body fat levels of many wrestlers are still well below their peers during off-season and are often as low as 3% during wrestling season. Of concern is a recently recognized body-image disorder, referred to as muscle dysmorphia, that occurs mostly in men who are preoccupied with weight lifting and perceive themselves as puny.
Men and Women in the Military. Studies are also showing a higher-than-average risk for eating disorders in men and women in the military. A study of eating behavior on one Army base reported that 8% of the women had an eating disorder, compared to 1% to 3% in the civilian female population.
[For more detail, see Excess Athleticism under What Causes Eating Disorders?]
Vegetarians
Studies report that vegetarianism in adolescence is a risk factor for eating disorder in both males and females. In one study, while these teens appear to eat more fruits and vegetables, they are also twice as likely to diet frequently, four times as likely to intensively diet, and eight times as likely to use laxatives as their non-vegetarian peers. This study does not mean that being a vegetarian equals having an eating disorder. It does suggest, however, that parents with children who suddenly become vegetarian, should be sure their children are eating a balanced meal with sufficient calories. Anorexic behavior in vegetarians should be suspected under certain conditions:
Young People with Diabetes or Other Chronic Diseases
According to one survey, 10.3% of teenage girls and 6.9% of boys with chronic illness, such as diabetes or asthma, had an eating disorder.
Diabetes. Eating disorders are particularly serious problems in people with either type 1 or type 2 diabetes.
Early Puberty
There is a greater risk for eating disorders and other emotional problems in girls who undergo early puberty, when the pressures experienced by all adolescents are intensified by experiencing, possibly alone, these early physical changes, including normal increased body fat. One interesting study reported the following:
This study was reporting on girls without eating disorders, but it certainly suggests patterns that can lead to eating problems, particularly in girls who go through puberty early.
WHAT CAUSES EATING DISORDERS?
There is no single cause for eating disorders. Although concerns about weight and body shape underlie all eating disorders, the actual cause of these disorders appear to result from a convergence of many factors, including cultural and family pressures and emotional and personality disorders. Genetics and biologic factors may also play a role.
Personality Disorders
A 2000 study reported that people with eating disorders tended to share similar personality traits, including low self-esteem, dependency, and problems with self-direction. Researchers have been attempting to determine specific personality disorders or behavioral characteristics that might put people at higher risk for one or both of the eating disorders. Some studies have reported the following personality disorders linked to particular eating disorders:
Avoidant Personalities. Some studies indicate that as many as a third of anorexia restrictors have avoidant personalities. This personality disorder is characterized by the following:
The person with both anorexia and avoidant personality disorder may hypothetically develop a behavioral and eating pattern as follows:
Although people with eating disorders are not typically suicidal, one expert described her anorexic patients as having a total lack of self, well beyond having low self-esteem. The process of not-eating, then, becomes an act of passive revenge on those whose love is always out of reach: "See? I am slowly disappearing, and you will be very sad when I am gone."
Borderline Personalities. Studies indicate that almost 40% of people who are diagnosed with bulimic anorexia (who lose weight by bingeing and purging) may have borderline personalities. Such people tend to have the following characteristics:
Some research has suggested that the severity of this personality disorder predicts difficulty in treating bulimia, and it might be more important than the presence of psychological problems, such as depression.
Narcissism. Studies have also found that people with bulimia or anorexia are often highly narcissistic and manifest the following personality traits:
Accompanying Emotional Disorders
Between 40% and 96% of all eating-disordered patients experience depression and anxiety disorders. Depression, anxiety, or both is also common in families of patients with eating disorders. It is not clear if emotional disorders, particularly obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), are actual causes of the eating disorders, increase susceptibility to them, or share common biologic cause.
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). Obsessive-compulsive disorder is an anxiety disorder that occurs in up to 69% of patients with anorexia and up to 33% of patients with bulimia. In fact, some experts believe that eating disorders are just variants of OCD. Obsessions are recurrent or persistent mental images, thoughts, or ideas, which may result in compulsive behavior, repetitive, rigid, and self-prescribed routines that are intended to prevent the manifestation of the obsession. Women with anorexia and OCD may become obsessed with exercise, dieting, and food. They often develop compulsive rituals, eg, weighing every bit of food, cutting it into tiny pieces, or putting it into tiny containers. The presence of OCD with either anorexia or bulimia does not, however, appear to have any effect on whether a patient improves or not.
Other Anxiety Disorders. A number of other anxiety disorders have been associated with both bulimia and anorexia.
Depression. Depression is common in people with eating disorders, particularly anorexia. Depression and eating disorders are also linked to a similar seasonal pattern, as indicated by the following observations:
Major depression is unlikely to be a cause of eating disorders, however, because treating and relieving depression rarely cures an eating disorder. The severity of the eating disorder is also not correlated with the severity of any existing depression. In addition, depression often improves after anorexic patients begin to gain weight.
Body Image Disorders
Body Dysmorphic Disorder. Body dysmorphic disorder involves a distorted view of one's body that is caused by social, psychologic, or possibly biologic factors. It is often associated with anorexia or bulimia, but it can also occur without any eating disorder. People with this disorder also commonly suffer from emotional disorders, including obsessive-compulsive disorder and depression.
Muscle Dysmorphia. Experts are also increasingly reporting a disorder in which people have distorted body images involving their muscles. It tends to occur in men who perceive themselves as being "puny" and results in excessive body building, preoccupation with diet, and social problems.
Negative Family Influences
Negative influences within the family play a major role in triggering and perpetuating eating disorders. Some studies have produced the following observations and theories regarding family influence.
At least one study has reported that the most positive way for parents to influence their children's eating habits and prevent weight problems and eating disorders is to have healthy eating habits themselves.
Problems Surrounding Birth
In some studies people with anorexia have reported a higher than average incidence of problems during the mother's pregnancy or after birth. These problems include the following:
Some experts believe, then, that such patients experienced some injury to the brain while in the womb that predisposed them to eating problems in infancy and subsequent eating disorders later in life. Studies have suggested that people with anorexia often had stomach and intestinal problems in infancy.
Genetic Factors
Anorexia is eight times more common in people who have relatives with the disorder, and some experts estimate that genetic factors may influence more than half of the variances in eating disorders. For example, a 2000 study reported that twins had a tendency to share specific eating disorders (anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and obesity). Some evidence has reported an association with genetic factors responsible for serotonin, the brain chemical involved with both well-being and appetite. Some inherited traits that might make someone susceptible to eating disorders include the following:
Cultural Pressures
One interesting anthropologic study reported the following observations:
Whether or not the current Western cultural pressure is for fewer children, the response of the media to both the cultural drive for thinness and overproduction of food play major roles in triggering obesity and eating disorders.
In a country where obesity is epidemic, young women who achieve thinness believe they have accomplished a major cultural and personal victory; they have overcome the temptations of junk food and, at the same time, created body images idealized by the media. Weight loss brings a feeling of triumph over helplessness. This sense of accomplishment is often reinforced by the envy of heavier companions who perceive the anorexic friend as being emotionally stronger and more sexually attractive than they are.
Excessive Athleticism and the Female Athlete Triad
The cultural attitude toward physical activity is a fitting companion to the general disordered attitude regarding eating. Americans are encouraged to admire physical activity only as an intense competitive effort that few can attain, leaving most people in their armchairs as spectators.
In the small community of athletes, excessive exercise plays a major role in many cases of anorexia (and, to a lesser degree, bulimia). In young female athletes, anorexia postpones puberty, allowing them to retain a muscular boyish shape without the normal accumulation of fatty tissues in breasts and hips that may blunt their competitive edge. Many coaches and teachers compound the problem by overstressing calorie counting and loss of body fat. Some over-control the athletes' lives and are even abusive to an athlete that goes over the weight limit. (Male athletes are also vulnerable to their coaches' influence and anorexia is also a problem among this group.)
In response, people who are vulnerable to such criticism may lose excessive weight, which has been known to be deadly even for famous athletes. The term "female athlete triad" in fact, is now a common and serious disorder facing young female athletes and dancers and describes the combined presence of the following problems:
In one study, female athletes who consumed a high-fat diet (35% of daily calories) performed longer and with greater intensity than those with a standard athletic low-fat diet (27% of daily calories). And such a diet appeared to be more estrogen-protective.
Hormonal Abnormalities
Hormonal problems are rampant in eating disorders and include chemical abnormalities in the thyroid, the reproductive regions, and areas related to stress, well-being, and appetite. Many of these chemical changes are certainly a result of malnutrition or other aspects of eating disorders, but they also may play a role in perpetuating or even creating susceptibility to the disorders.
The primary setting of many of these abnormalities originate in a small area of the brain called the limbic system. A specific system called hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis (HPA) may be particularly important in eating disorders. It originates in the following regions in the brain:
Stress Hormones. The HPA systems trigger the production and release of stress hormones called glucocorticoids, including the primary stress hormone cortisol. Chronically elevated levels of stress chemicals have been observed in patients with anorexia and bulimia. Cortisol is very important in marshaling systems throughout the body (including the heart, lungs, circulation, metabolism, immune systems, and skin) to deal quickly with any threat. Among the specific effects is inhibition of neuropeptide Y (NPY), a powerful appetite stimulant that also has anti-anxiety properties. This process may serve as a biologic link between extreme stressful conditions in a young person's life and the later development of anorexia, although some imaging studies indicate that stress-hormone related changes occur after anorexia has developed. More work is needed to determine if changes in stress hormones are a cause or result of eating disorders.
Release of Neurotransmitters. The HPA system also releases certain neurotransmitters (chemical messengers) that regulate stress, mood, and appetite and are being heavily investigated for a possible role in eating disorders. Abnormalities in the activities of three of them, serotonin, norepinephrine, and dopamine, are of particular interest. Serotonin is involved with both well-being and appetite (among other traits), and norepinephrine is a stress hormone. Abnormalities in both have been observed in patients who binge and in those with anorexia or bulimia. Dopamine is involved in reward-seeking behavior, so deficiencies might create a more intense need for rewards, such as carbohydrates. Studies on dopamine abnormalities have been mixed, however.
Low-Leptin Levels. Leptin is a hormone that appears to trigger the hypothalamus to stimulate appetite, and low levels have been observed in people with anorexia and bulimia.
Low Reproductive Hormones. The hypothalamic-pituitary system is also responsible for the production of important reproductive hormones that are severely depleted in anorexics. Although most experts believe that these reproductive abnormalities are a result of anorexia, others have reported that in 30% to 50% of people with anorexia, menstrual disturbances occurred before severe malnutrition set in and remained a problem long after weight gain, indicating that hypothalamic-pituitary abnormalities precede the eating disorder itself.
Compensating for Mood Swings during Binge-Purging Cycles
Serotonin Imbalances. Low levels of serotonin have been observed not only in eating disorders but also in depression. One theory for the persistence of the binge-purge cycle in bulimia involves restoring serotonin imbalances and so improving mood. It involves the following:
Infections
In some cases, infection has been associated with anorexia. Immune factors released to fight these infections may cause inflammation and injury in the areas of the brain that affect appetite and behavior.
Streptococcal Infection. Research has found a link between anorexia and group A beta-hemolytic streptococcal (GABHS) bacteria, the cause of strep throat. GABHS has already been identified as a trigger of a rare form of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) in children, which often accompanies eating disorders.
Epstein Barr. Epstein Barr, the virus that causes mononucleosis has also been associated with the development of anorexia.
HOW SERIOUS IS BULIMIA NERVOSA WITHOUT SERIOUS WEIGHT LOSS (ANOREXIA)?
Chances for Recovery
Some studies have suggested that between 60% and 80% of patients are in remission within three months of treatment. However, relapse is common and up to half of women with bulimia continue to battle disordered eating habits for years, with bulimia itself persisting in 10% to 25% of patients.
Medical Consequences
In general, there are few major health problems for bulimic people who maintain normal weight and do not go on to become anorexic. For example, one study comparing adolescents with anorexia and bulimia reported abnormal heart rhythms in patients with anorexia but not in those with bulimia. It should be noted, however, that in one study of bulimic patients undergoing therapy, after six years the mortality rate was 1%. Those who have both bulimia and anorexia, however, are in great danger. [ See How Serious Is Anorexia Nervosa? below.]
And, the disorder, even without anorexia, is not without health problems and serious risks. The following are medical problems associated with bulimia:
Self-Destructive Behavior
A number of self-destructive behaviors occur with bulimia:
Abuse of Over-the-Counter Medications
Women with bulimia frequently abuse over-the-counter medications, such as laxatives, appetite suppressants, diuretics, and drugs (e.g., ipecac) that induce vomiting. None of these drugs is without risk. For example, ipecac poisonings have been reported, and some people become dependent on laxatives for normal bowel functioning. Diet pills, even herbal and over-the-counter medications, can be hazardous, particularly if they are abused.
HOW SERIOUS IS ANOREXIA NERVOSA?
Chances for Recovery
At this time no treatment program for anorexia nervosa is completely effective, and about 50% of patients never achieve a normal weight. Many still display traits characteristic of the disorder, including perfectionism and a drive for thinness, that could keep them at risk for recurrence of the eating disorder. Even in those who recover, one study indicated that recovery took between four and nearly seven years.
Risk Factors for Early Mortality
Studies of anorexic patients have reported death rates ranging from 4% to 25%. According to different studies, the risk for early death is higher in the people with the following conditions or characteristics:
Suicide
Suicide has been estimated in some studies to account for as many as half the deaths in anorexia. In one study, suicide rates occurred in 1.4% of women with anorexia. The study, however, only looked at female death records. Such records may not have always recorded anorexia as an accompanying condition, so the incidence of suicide in anorexia may be much higher.
Heart Disease
Heart disease is the most common medical cause of death in people with severe anorexia. The effects of anorexia on the heart are as follows:
A primary danger to the heart is from abnormalities in the balance of minerals, such as potassium, calcium, magnesium, and phosphate, which are normally dissolved in the body's fluid. The dehydration and starvation that occurs with anorexia can reduce fluid and mineral levels and produce a condition known as electrolyte imbalance . Electrolytes of calcium and potassium are critical for maintaining the electric currents necessary for a normal heart beat. An imbalance in these electrolytes, then, can be very serious and even life-threatening unless fluids and minerals are replaced. Heart problems are a particular risk when anorexia is compounded by bulimia and the use of ipecac, a drug that causes vomiting.
Medical Consequences of Hormonal Changes
Anorexia has a number of hormonal effects that can have severe health consequences:
The result of many of these hormonal abnormalities in women is long-term, irregular or absent menstruation (amenorrhea). This can occur early on in anorexia, even before severe weight loss. Over time this causes infertility and bone loss. Low weight alone may not be sufficient to cause amenorrhea. Extreme fasting and purging behaviors may play an even stronger role in hormonal disturbance.
Long-Term Outlook on Fertility. After treatment and weight increase, estrogen levels are usually restored and periods resume. In severe anorexia, however, even after treatment, normal menstruation never returns in 25% of such patients.
Long-Term Effect on Bones . Loss of bone minerals (osteopenia) and loss of bone density (osteoporosis) is a common result of low estrogen levels in women with anorexia. Bone loss in such women may also be worsened by low calcium levels and by higher levels of stress hormones (which impair bone growth). Up to two-thirds of children and adolescent girls with anorexia fail to develop strong bones during their critical growing period. The less the patient weighs, the more severe the bone loss. Women with anorexia who also binge-purge face an even higher risk for bone loss.
Weight gain, unfortunately, does not restore bone. Only achieving regular menstruation as soon as possible can protect against permanent bone loss. The longer the eating disorder persists the more likely the bone loss will be permanent.
Neurological Problems
People with severe anorexia may suffer nerve damage that affects the brain and other parts of the body. The following nerve-related conditions have been reported:
Brains scans indicate that parts of the brain undergo structural changes and abnormal activity during anorexic states. Some of these changes return to normal after weight gain, but there is evidence that some damage may be permanent. Still, the extent of the neurologic problems is unclear, and some studies have been unable to determine specific mental problems associated with anorexia.
Blood Problems
Anemia is a common result of anorexia and starvation. A particularly serious blood problem is pernicious anemia, which can be caused by severely low levels of vitamin B12. If anorexia becomes extreme, the bone marrow dramatically reduces its production of blood cells, a life-threatening condition called pancytopenia.
Gastrointestinal Problems
Bloating and constipation are both very common problems in people with anorexia.
Multiorgan Failure
In very late anorexia, the organs simply fail. The main signal for this is elevated levels of liver enzymes, which require immediate administration of calories.
Complications in Diabetic Adolescents
Eating disorders are very serious in young people with type 1 diabetes. The complications of anorexia that affect all patients are even more dangerous in this group of patients. Hypoglycemia, or low blood sugar, for example, is a danger in anyone with anorexia, but it is a particularly dangerous risk in those with diabetes. One study found that 85% of young women with diabetes and eating disorders had retinopathy, damage to the retina in the eye, which can lead to blindness.
Drug and Alcohol Abuse
Some studies estimate that between 12% and 18% of people who are anorexic also abuse alcohol or drugs.
WHAT ARE THE SYMPTOMS OF EATING DISORDERS?
Distorted Body Image
Possibly the most bewildering symptom of both eating disorders is the distorted body image ( body dysmorphia ). Although people typically associate distorted body image with severe anorexia, one study indicated that distortion may be more prevalent in people with bulimia. People with bulimia were more likely than those with anorexia to overestimate their size. There was also a greater disparity between what they wanted to look like and what they believed they looked like. In another study, people with anorexia tended to have an accurate perception of their upper body, but overestimated the size of their abdominal and pelvic area.
Symptoms Specific to Bulimia without Anorexia
People with bulimia nearly always practice it in secret, and, although they may be underweight, they are not always anorexic. Symptoms or signs of bulimia, then, may be very subtle and go unnoticed. They may include the following:
Symptoms Specific to Anorexia
Weight Loss. The primary symptom of anorexia is major weight loss from excessive and continuous dieting, which may either be restrictive dieting or binge-eating and purging. Note. Young women who have both diabetes and eating disorders may have normal weight or even be overweight from the effects of insulin. However, they still are at high risk from the medical consequences of anorexia.
Other Symptoms. Other symptoms may include the following:
WHAT WILL CONFIRM A DIAGNOSIS OF EATING DISORDERS?
Admitting the Problem
The first step toward a diagnosis is to admit the existence of an eating disorder. Often, the patient needs to be compelled by a parent or others to see a doctor because the patient may deny and resist the problem. Some patients may even self-diagnose their condition as an allergy to carbohydrates, because after being on a restricted diet, eating carbohydrates can produce gastrointestinal problems, dizziness, weakness, and palpitations. This may lead such people to restrict carbohydrates even more severely.
It is often extremely difficult for parents as well as the patient to admit that a problem is present. For example, because food is such an intrinsic part of the mother/child relationship, a child's eating disorder might seem like a terrible parental failure. Parents themselves may have their own emotional issues with weight gain and loss and perceive no problem in having a "thin" child.
Interview Tests
It is recommended that a supportive companion be present during part of the initial medical interview to offer additional information on the patient's eating history and to help offset any resistance or denial the patient may express.
Various questionnaires are available for assessing patients. For example, a brief British test called the SCOFF questionnaire is proving to be very reliable in accurately identifying people who are at high risk for either eating disorder [ see Box SCOFF Questionnaire]:
|
SCOFF Questionnaire S Do you feel Sick because you feel full?C Do you lose Control over how much you eat? O Have you lost more than One stone (about 13 pounds) recently? F Do you believe yourself to be Fat when others say you are thin? F Does Food dominate your life? Answering yes to two of these questions is a strong indicator of an eating disorder. |
Diagnosing Bulimia Nervosa
In spite of the prevalence of bulimia, in one study only 30% of Midwest family physicians had ever diagnosed bulimia in a patient. Younger and female physicians are more likely to detect bulimia. A physician should make a diagnosis of bulimia if there are at least two bulimic episodes per week for three months. Because people with bulimia tend to have complications with their teeth and gums, dentists could play a crucial role in identifying and diagnosing bulimia.
Diagnosing Anorexia Nervosa
Generally, an observation of physical symptoms and a personal history will quickly confirm the diagnosis of anorexia. The standard criteria for diagnosing anorexia nervosa are:
The physician then categorizes the anorexia further:
Because the disorder rarely shows up in men, physicians may not be on the look out for it in male patients, even if they show classic symptoms of anorexia. Physicians should be very aware of these symptoms in anyone, particularly in athletes and dancers.
Diagnosing Complications of Eating Disorders
Once a diagnosis is made, physicians should immediately check for any serious complications of starvation. They should also rule out other medical disorders that might be causing the anorexia. Tests should include the following:
WHAT ARE THE GENERAL GUIDELINES FOR TREATING EATING DISORDERS?
Overcoming Resistance to Initial Treatment
The first major difficulty in treating eating disorders is often the resistance by everyone involved:
It is very important that the patient and any close friends and relatives be informed about the serious potential of these conditions and the importance of receiving immediate help.
Getting Rid of Unrealistic Expectations
Patients may drop out of programs if they have unrealistic expectations of being "cured" simply through the therapists' insights. Before a program begins, the following possibilities should be made clear:
Although outcome in bulimia is generally more favorable than in anorexia, long-term studies are showing recovery in most people treated for anorexia.
General Treatment Approaches
Psychotherapies. All eating disorders are nearly always treated with some form of psychiatric or psychologic treatment. Depending on the problem, different psychologic approaches may work better than others. A 2001 study reported that patients at greater risk for not completing therapy are those with a history of childhood trauma (eg, divorce, abuse). Drop-out rates were not related to the severity or duration of the disorder.
Medications. A number of medications may be valuable for these patients depending on the type of eating disorder, psychiatric state, and severity of the condition.
[For specific information see treatment sections on either bulimia or anorexia and also What Are the General Psychologic Approaches Used in Eating Disorders? below.]
WHAT ARE SPECIFIC TREATMENTS FOR PATIENTS WHO HAVE BULIMIA WITHOUT WEIGHT LOSS?
Stepped-Care Approach for Patients with Bulimia
Some experts recommend a stepped approach to patients with bulimia, which may follow these stages, depending on the severity and response to initial treatments:
Patients with bulimia rarely need hospitalization except under the following circumstances:
Psychotherapeutic Approaches for Bulimia
Drug Therapy for Bulimia Nervosa
Antidepressants. Because of the high incidence of depression in patients with bulimia, antidepressant medication is often recommended for patients who have normal weight or for those who are overweight. The most common antidepressants prescribed for bulimia are selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs). They include fluoxetine (Prozac), sertraline (Zoloft), paroxetine (Paxil), venlafaxine (Effexor), and fluvoxamine (Luvox). Prozac has been approved for bulimia and is considered the drug of choice, although many other SSRIs are probably as effective. Studies suggest that SSRIs may reduce binge eating by 67% and vomiting by 56%. (Adding cognitive-behavioral therapy improves success rates.)
If the drugs are not effective, the physician should be sure it is not because the patient is vomiting after taking the medication. Some experts believe that these agents should be continued even after symptoms have improved in order to restore healthy brain chemical balances.
Agents to Prevent Vomiting. In one study, ondansetron, a drug that prevents vomiting, reduced the binge-purge episodes by half. The drug may cause depression in people already on SSRI antidepressants. More studies are needed.
Sibutramine. Sibutramine (Meridia) is a drug used for weight loss. It does so by keeping two important brain chemicals, serotonin and norepinephrine, in balance, which helps to increase metabolism. Some evidence suggests that the actions of this drug may be useful for people who binge. Note, however, that in bulimic patients this agent should be used only for those with normal or above normal weight and never for those who are anorexic.
Inositol. Inositol is a B vitamin that is being investigated for bipolar, anxiety, and depression. A 2001 study suggests that it may have benefits for bulimic patients.
Alternative and Other Approaches to Bulimia
Hypnosis. A study on women with bulimia showed that they had a high susceptibility to hypnosis, suggesting that it might be beneficial as part of their treatment. People with anorexia, on the other hand, seem to be very resistant to the state of vulnerability required in this process.
Light Therapy. Some researchers have noted an association between bulimia and seasonal affective disorder (depression that intensifies in the darker winter months); this suggests that therapy using intense directed light may be useful. Studies report, however, that while light therapy relieves depression, it has little effect on binge-purging behavior. Some experts suggest it may be more useful combination with medication and psychotherapy.
Guided Imagery. A technique called guided imagery reduced frequency of binges and vomiting by almost 75% in one study; this method uses audio tapes to evoke images that will reduce stress and help achieve specific goals.
Breast Reduction Surgery. Although women with eating disorders are ordinarily disqualified from plastic surgery, two small studies reported that in women whose bulimia was triggered by over-sized breasts, reduction surgery was effective in resolving the eating disorder.
WHAT ARE SPECIFIC TREATMENTS FOR PATIENTS WITH ANOREXIA
Patients with severe anorexia need intensive treatment, which often includes hospitalization and a team approach. It is a very difficult disorder and the treatments used for bulimia are not as effective for this problem. Early intervention is needed to prevent the health problems associated with this problem, which can be severe.
Initial Approach to Severe Anorexia
Treating Medical Problems. Physicians should immediately check and treat any medical problems related to the condition, such as bone loss, imbalances in important electrolytes, and any hormonal deficiencies, including thyroid and reproductive hormones.
Hospitalization. Many moderately to severely ill anorexic patients require hospitalization for initial treatment, particularly under the following circumstances:
In some severe cases, patients with anorexia may need to be hospitalized involuntarily. A 2000 study reported that such patients respond as well as patients who were admitted voluntarily. And, most later agreed that such treatment had been necessary.
Unfortunately, insurance companies rarely cover more than 15 days in the hospital. In people with severe anorexia, however, many experts believe that 10 to 12 weeks of hospitalization with full nutritional support are required to reach ideal body weight. Certainly 15 days is not enough to make major changes to entrenched behavior.
According to one study, patients at particular danger from early release have the following characteristics:
It is particularly critical for women with both diabetes and anorexia to achieve 100% of ideal weight before being released.
Team Approaches. A multidisciplinary team approach with consistent support and counseling is essential for long-term recovery from all severe eating disorders. Depending on the severity and type of disorder, team members may include the following:
All should be skilled in treating eating disorders. Studies have found that people treated by such specialists have a lower mortality rate than those treated only as psychiatric patients.
|
Measuring Body Mass Index The body mass index (BMI) is the measurement of body fat. It is derived by multiplying a person's weight in pounds by 703 and then dividing it twice by the height in inches.
For example, a woman who is 5'5" and weights 125 pounds has a healthy BMI of 21. A woman at the same height who weighs 90 pounds would have a dangerously low BMI of 15. |
Restoring Normal Weight
In addition to immediate treatment of any serious medical problem, the goal of therapy for the anorexic person is to increase weight. Usually this involves the following steps:
Tube or intravenous feeding is rarely needed or recommended unless the patient's condition is life threatening. Overzealous administration of glucose solutions can trigger the so-called refeeding syndrom e, in which phosphate levels drop severely and cause a condition called hypophosphatemia. Emergency symptoms include irritability, muscle weakness, bleeding from the mouth, disturbed heart rhythms, seizures, and coma.
The Role of Exercise. For those with anorexia, excessive exercise is often a component of the original disorder. During the recovery program, very controlled exercise regimens may be used as both a reward for developing good eating habits and as a way to reduce the stomach and intestinal distress that accompanies recovery. Exercise should not be performed if severe medical problems still exist and if the patient has not gained significant weight.
Psychologic Approaches for Patients with Anorexia
Some studies suggest that for adolescents with anorexia, family therapy that employs cognitive-behavioral techniques works best. For those with late-onset anorexia, individual supportive therapy may be more effective. Family therapy is important for younger and older individuals. It should be noted that people with severe anorexia often have mental deficits and may not respond well to psychologic therapies until they have regained weight. [For more detailed information see What Are the Psychologic Approaches Used in Eating Disorders?]
Drug Therapy for Anorexia
Antidepressants. Studies have not reported many benefits from selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), the antidepressants that are often useful for patients with bulimia. In fact, the effects of starvation may intensify their side effects and reduce effectiveness in patients with anorexia. Nevertheless, few studies have actually been conducted, particularly on some of the newer agents. Some, in fact, suggest that SSRIs may help prevent relapse in patients who have been treated and have restored weight. And a small study on sertraline (Zoloft) reported improvement in patients who were initially treated with the SSRI. These agents may also be useful for people with anorexia who also have obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). More work is needed to determine if there is a possible role for these agents. [For a description of SSRIs, see What Are Specific Treatments for Patients Who Have Bulimia without Weight Loss?]
Anti-Anxiety Agents. Patients with anxiety disorders and anorexia may also benefit from other agents that treat anxiety. [ See the Well-Connected report Anxiety.]
Appetite Stimulants. Some physicians recommend cyproheptadine (Periactin), an antihistamine, that may stimulate appetite. (It is not useful for patients with bulimia and may even slow recovery.)
Atypical Antipsychotics. Certain agents, called atypical antipsychotics, are currently used for schizophrenia and bipolar disorders. Not only are they useful for stabilizing mood but they also produce significant weight gain. Specific agents that may be helpful for patients with severe treatment-resistant anorexia include olanzapine (Zyprexa) and amisulpride (Solian).
Agents to Restore Hormonal Function and Bone Density. Normalizing reproductive hormone balances is more important than weight gain in restoring menstrual function. The use of oral contraceptives (OCs) have had mixed results. Some studies have found no improvement in bone density with the use of estrogen. Other studies found that OCs containing estrogen may improve bone density in the spine and overall, although not in the hip.
Patients should take supplements of 1,000 to 1,500 mg of calcium and a multivitamin containing 400 IU of vitamin D. Other drugs are useful for bone restoration, including parathyroid hormone and bisphosphonates, although research on these agents have been conducted primarily on postmenopausal women.
WHAT ARE THE GENERAL PSYCHOLOGIC APPROACHES USED IN EATING DISORDERS?
Eating disorders are nearly always treated with some form of psychiatric or psychologic treatment. Depending on the problem, different psychologic approaches may work better than others.
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy
Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) works on the principle that a pattern of false thinking and belief about one's body can be recognized objectively and altered, thereby changing the response and eliminating the unhealthy reaction to food. One approach for bulimia is the following:
Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT). This approach uses cognitive techniques but was developed specifically for people with borderline personality disorder. It is now showing promise for patients with bulimia. It employs four goals for the patient:
Interpersonal Therapy
Interpersonal therapy deals with depression or anxiety that might underlie the eating disorders along with social factors that influence eating behavior. This therapy does not deal with weight, food, or body image at all.
The goals are the following:
Studies generally report that it is not as effective as cognitive therapy for bulimia and binge-eating, but may be useful for some patients with anorexia. The skill of the therapist plays a strong role in its success.
Family Therapy
Because of the major role family attitudes play in eating disorders, one of the first steps in treating the patient with early-onset anorexia is to also treat the family. Family therapy is certainly useful for both younger and older patients.
If the patient is hospitalized, experts recommend that family therapy start after the patient has gained weight, but before discharge. It should usually continue after the patient has left the hospital.
The feelings of intense guilt and anxiety that caregivers experience are probably similar to those produced by living with a person who is suicidal. An over-involved parent may even support the patient's eating disorder for various reasons:
In such cases, it is extremely important that the family fully understand the danger of this disorder and that they are collaborating in their child's illness, or even death, by encouraging this state.
WHERE ELSE CAN SOMEONE GET HELP FOR AN EATING DISORDER?
National Association of Anorexia Nervosa and Associated Disorders (ANAD), PO Box 7, Highland Park, IL 60035. Call (847-831-3438) or (http://www.anad.org/)
This is the oldest organization for eating disorders. They offer free information and help in finding or forming support groups in local areas. For an annual contribution of $25, members receive a quarterly newsletter.
Eating Disorders Awareness and Prevention, 603 Stewart Street, Suite 803, Seattle, WA 98101.
Call (206-382-3587) or (800-931-2237) or (http://www.nationaleatingdisorders.org/)
Anorexia Nervosa and Related Eating Disorders (ANRED). Box 5102, Eugene, OR 97405.
Call (541-344-1144) or (http://www.anred.com)
Offers free and low-cost information packets on eating disorders.
The Eating Disorders Coalition Call (202-543-3842) or (http://www.eatingdisorderscoalition.org)
This is an advocacy group to promote federal funding for eating disorders.
American Dietetic Association, 216 W. Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois 60606. Call (800-877-1600) or (312-899-0040) or (http://www.eatright.org/)
The organization offers a hot-line that allows people to speak to a licensed dietitian and also provides names of licensed dietitians for specific locations. Its web site is excellent and highly recommended.
International Eating Disorder Referral Organization. Eating Disorder Referral and Information Center, 2923 Sandy Pointe Suite, 6 Del Mar, CA 92014-2052. Call (858-481-1515) or (http://www.edreferral.com)
Association for Advancement of Behavior Therapy, 305 Seventh Ave., 16th Fl., New York, NY 10001. Call (800-685-2228) or (212-647-1890) or (http://www.aabt.org/)
Offers information packets that include a list of behavior therapists, fact sheets on various psychological problems, and methods for choosing a therapist.
American Institute for Cognitive Therapy. Call (212-308-2440) or (http://www.cognitivetherapynyc.com/)
The American Psychiatric Association. Call (888-357-7924) or (http://www.psych.org/)
The American Psychological Association. Call (202-783-2077) or (http://www.psychologicalscience.org/)
The National Association of Social Workers. Call (202-408-8600) or (http://www.naswdc.org/)
The American Psychiatric Nurses Association. Call (703-243-2443) or (http://www.apna.org/)
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (http://www.aacap.org/)
Other useful eating disorders web sites:
This is an odd personal site but has excellent information and support on eating disorders. (http://www.something-fishy.org/)
Site for family members and patients (http://closetoyou.org/eatingdisorders/)
Interesting site assists in finding the right therapist (http://www.1-800-therapist.com/)
An online catalog that offers kitchen products, bathroom helpers and daily living products for people of all ages and abilities or disabilities.(http://www.dynamic-living.com)
RECENT LITERATURE
Review Date: March 2002
This Report Reviewed by:
Harvey Simon, MD, Editor-in-Chief, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Theodore A. Stern, MD, Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School; Psychiatrist and Chief, Psychiatric Consultation Service, Massachusetts General Hospital
ABOUT WELL-CONNECTED
Well-Connected reports are written and updated by experienced medical writers and reviewed and edited by the in-house editors and a board of physicians who have faculty positions at Harvard Medical School and Massachusetts General Hospital. Neither Harvard Medical School nor Massachusetts General Hospital, as institutions, review or endorse their content. The reports are distinguished from other information sources available to patients and health care consumers by their quality, detail of information, and currency. These reports are not intended as a substitute for medical professional help or advice but are to be used only as an aid in understanding current medical knowledge. A physician should always be consulted for any health problem or medical condition. The reports may not be copied without the express permission of the publisher.
Board of Editors
Harvey Simon, MD, Editor-in-Chief, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Stephen A. Cannistra, MD, Oncology, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Director, Gynecologic Medical Oncology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
John E. Godine, MD, PhD, Metabolism, Harvard Medical School; Associate Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Edwin Huang, MD, Gynecology, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Daniel Heller, MD, Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School; Associate Pediatrician, Massachusetts General Hospital; Active Staff, Children's Hospital
Paul C. Shellito, MD, Surgery, Harvard Medical School; Associate Visiting Surgeon, Massachusetts General Hospital
Theodore A. Stern, MD, Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School; Psychiatrist and Chief, Psychiatric Consultation Service, Massachusetts General Hospital
Nidus Information Services
Cynthia Chevins, Publisher
Bruce Carlson, Business Development Manager
Carol Peckham, Editorial Director
Sherry Knecht, Update Editor
Nidus Information Services, Inc., 41 East 11th Street, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10003 or email office@well-connected.com or on the Internet at www.well-connected.com
©2002 A.D.A.M., Inc. (or its subsidiaries)