
Tony Lambert delphine1939@videotron.ca
5 Janvier 2007
Schizophrenia
March 2002
The term schizophrenia was first used in 1911 by Eugen Bleuler, a Swiss psychiatrist, to categorize patients whose thought processes and emotional responses seemed disconnected. The term schizophrenia literally means split mind; however, many people still believe incorrectly that the condition causes a split personality (which is an uncommon problem involving dissociation).
Schizophrenia is now used to describe a cluster of symptoms that typically includes the following:
Because symptoms of schizophrenia arise from various physical processes and respond differently to treatments, some experts recommend classifying the disease based on the presence of the following symptom groups:
The disease is complicated by the fact that although a schizophrenic patient may have more than one symptom, he or she rarely has all of them. Symptoms also often go into remission. As the mechanisms in the brain that lead to schizophrenia are being discovered, researchers are attempting to define more accurate ways of describing the disease as it relates to the biologic processes that cause them.
Negative Symptoms
Negative symptoms reflect the following states:
Often certain negative symptoms (e.g., lack of responsiveness and poor sociability) appear in childhood as the first indications of schizophrenia. Certain imaging techniques suggest that these findings are based on biologic changes in specific parts of the brain. In many patients, however, negative symptoms do not appear until after positive symptoms develop. Negative symptoms tend to be more common than positive symptoms in older patients and typically persist after positive symptoms have been treated.
Psychotic Symptoms
Psychotic symptoms, particularly delusions and hallucinations, are the most widely recognized manifestations of schizophrenia.
After the initial event, psychotic symptoms usually occur episodically and are interspersed with periods of remission. They typically occur in men between the ages of 17 and 30 and in women between the ages of 20 and 40.
Cognitive Impairment (Disordered Thinking)
The symptoms of cognitive impairment and disordered thinking include the following and may occur before other symptoms of schizophrenia:
In summary, people with schizophrenia do poorly on mental tasks requiring conscious awareness, such as verbal fluency, short-term and working memory, and processing speed. However, they are no worse than the general population in underlying (implicit) learning, such as grammar skills, vocabulary, and spatial skills (e.g., map reading). Some experts believe that impaired verbal memory in schizophrenia is a consequence of depression and slowness, but not a result of the disease process.
Other Symptoms
People with schizophrenia may experience other symptoms, such as intolerance of heat (which is associated with antipsychotic medications) and a reduced sense of smell.
WHAT CAUSES SCHIZOPHRENIA?
No single cause can account for all cases of schizophrenia. Rather, it appears to be the result of multiple hits from genetic factors, environmental and psychological assaults, and possible hormonal changes that alter the brain's chemistry and trigger this devastating disease.
Brain Structure and Circuitry
Abnormalities of Brain Volume and Activity. Imaging techniques have revealed reduced volume and actual loss of tissue in the brains of people with schizophrenia. Of particular importance are volume losses and abnormal activity in the prefrontal cortex and the temporal lobes .
Abnormal Brain Chemicals. Schizophrenia is associated with an unusual imbalance of neurotransmitters (chemical messengers between nerve cells) and other factors.
Genetic Factors
Schizophrenia undoubtedly has a genetic component. The risk for inheriting schizophrenia is 10% in those who have one immediate family member with the disease and about 40% if the disease affects both parents or an identical twin. Family members of patients also appear to have higher risks for the specific symptoms (i.e., negative or positive) of the relative with schizophrenia.
Researchers are seeking the specific genetic factors that may be responsible for structural brain abnormalities, including reduced brain size and enlarged ventricles, that have been observed in patients with schizophrenia and their families. For example an abnormal so- gene called COMT may make people susceptible to deficits in the prefrontal cortex of the brain, where schizophrenia develops.
It should be noted that heredity does not explain all cases of the disease, however. About 60% of people with schizophrenia have no close relatives with the illness.
Infectious Agents
Viruses. The case for viruses as a cause of this disease rests mainly on circumstantial evidence, such as living in crowded conditions. The following are some studies suggesting an association:
Loss of Oxygen around the Time of Birth
Many studies have reported an association between schizophrenia and problems surrounding birth, particularly those that cause oxygen deprivation, which could effect the nerve systems in the developing brain. Specific complications that have been associated with such a higher risk include the following:
Psychologic Factors
Although parental influence is no longer believed to play a major role in the development of schizophrenia, it would be irresponsible to ignore outside pressures and influences that may exacerbate or trigger symptoms. The prefrontal lobes of the brain, which are the brain areas often thought to lead to this disease, are extremely responsive to environmental stress. Given the fact that schizophrenic symptoms naturally elicit negative responses from the sufferer's circle of family and acquaintances, it is safe to assume that negative feedback can intensify deficits in a vulnerable brain and perhaps even trigger and exacerbate existing symptoms. One study to support this indicated that early parental loss, either from death or separation, increases the risk for psychiatric disorders, including schizophrenia. In another interesting 2000 study, criticism by family members was significantly correlated with the onset of disorganized thinking in patients with impaired working memory. (This effect of criticism was not observed in patients with functioning working memories.)
WHO DEVELOPS SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Schizophrenia is the most common psychotic condition; it affects about 1% of the earth's population, including more than 2.7 million people in America.
Age
Schizophrenia can occur at any age, but it tends to first develop (or at least become evident) between adolescence and young adulthood. Schizophrenia that is recognized in children is likely to be severe. Although the risk of schizophrenia declines with age, there is a lesser peak incidence at around 45 years and another, mostly in women, in the mid-60s. Late-onset schizophrenia that develops in the 40s is most likely to be the paranoid subtype with fewer negative symptoms or learning impairment. Such patients usually have functioned at a near-normal level until structural deficits in the brain break down.
Intelligence
Genius is not spared; schizophrenia's victims span the full range of intelligence. In fact, one study reported that a higher than expected number of people who develop schizophrenia had been intellectually gifted children. Research suggests, however, that a decline in IQ scores during childhood may be a harbinger of psychotic symptoms in adults.
Cultural and Geographic Factors
No cultural or geographic group is immune, although the course of the disease seems to be more severe in developed than in developing countries. Also, interestingly, the content of delusions may vary depending on a person's culture. According to one study, for example, European patients were more apt to have delusions of poisoning or religious guilt while in Japan the delusions were most often related to being slandered.
Socioeconomic Factors
The disease occurs twice as often in unmarried and divorced people as in married or widowed individuals. Furthermore, people with schizophrenia are eight times more likely to be in the lowest socioeconomic groups. These statistics are likely to reflect the alienating effects of this disease rather than any causal relationship or risk factor associated with poverty or a single life. Nevertheless, low income and poverty may increase the risk for exposure to biologic factors (e.g., infections or toxins) or social stressors that could trigger the illness in susceptible people.
Gender
Although schizophrenia affects both genders, there are some differences:
Other Factors Associated with Schizophrenia
Non-Right Handedness. The prevalence of mixed- and left-handedness is significantly higher in patients with schizophrenia than in the general population, suggesting some neurologic pattern that may be responsible for each. (A large minority of the population is non-right handed and very few of these people develop schizophrenia.)
Abnormal Olfactory Bulbs. Studies are reporting impairment in the sense of smell in patients with schizophrenia. One study reported abnormally small olfactory bulbs in patients with schizophrenia. Olfactory bulbs are nerve centers in the brain that regulate the sense of smell.
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder. Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) affects a significant number of schizophrenic patients. OCD is an anxiety disorder marked by obsessions (recurrent or persistent mental images, thoughts, or ideas) that may result in compulsive behaviors, repetitive, rigid, and self-prescribed routines that are intended to prevent the manifestation of the obsession. Some experts believe the behaviors exhibited in the disorder may actually be protective in people with schizophrenia in early stages.
Behavioral and Motor Problems in Childhood. Children who later develop schizophrenia often suffer from the following certain problems, including excessive shyness or minor early physical and motor-control problems. Such problems are so common, however, that their presence without any other risk factors is no cause for concern.
Malnutrition in the Pregnant Mother. Malnutrition in the mother during the first trimester of pregnancy (less than 1,000 calories a day) has been associated with later schizophrenia in the child. Nutritional deficiencies during that time are believed to impair fetal brain growth.
Father's Age. According to one 2001 study, the older a father is when a child is born, the greater the child's risk is for schizophrenia, perhaps because of a greater chance of genetic mutations in the sperm that can be passed on. In the study, children whose fathers were 50 years old or more or faced a three-fold risk for schizophrenia compared to children whose fathers were 25 or younger.
WHAT ARE THE SIGNS OF SCHIZOPHRENIA AND HOW DOES IT PROGRESS?
Early Symptoms of Schizophrenia in Childhood
Research indicates that symptoms in childhood strongly predict disease in adult. In one long-term study, over 40% of schizophrenics who developed the disease in young adulthood had reported psychotic symptoms at age 11. For children with a family history of schizophrenia, the following inherited traits may be warning signs:
Some experts suggest that screening young high-risk individuals using brain imaging techniques possibly followed by treatment may help prevent nerve damage and improve the outcome for this difficult disease.
Most often, early warning signs go unnoticed and schizophrenia usually becomes evident for the first time in late adolescence or early adulthood. Schizophrenia that starts in childhood or adolescence tends to be severe. It should be strongly noted that the traits discussed above, even combinations of them, can be present without schizophrenia.
Progression to Full-Blown Schizophrenia
The course of the disease varies from one patient to the next. Symptoms of psychosis can become evident either gradually or suddenly.
Typically, patients develop considerable cognitive dysfunction (disordered thinking) within the first four or five years of the onset of psychotic symptoms. There is some evidence that the physical disease process in schizophrenia is progressive, as with Alzheimer's and Parkinson's. However, schizophrenia does not progress in the same way as those two diseases. In one study, men with schizophrenia showed an annual decline of 3% in areas in the front of the brain compared to slightly less than 1% in men without schizophrenia. Unlike Parkinson's and Alzheimer's, however, eventually cognitive function usually stabilizes. Psychosis, disorganized thought, and negative symptoms often improve over time, although, even in such cases, deficits in verbal memory usually persist. (Thought disorder often improves in concert with improvements in negative symptoms.)
WHAT ARE THE EMOTIONAL, INTELLECTUAL, AND SOCIAL CONSEQUENCES OF SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Although there is no cure, new drugs are offering significant hope for improving the patient's life. Even with care and adequate treatment, however, people with schizophrenia suffer. The disease has a devastating effect on all aspects of human thought, emotion, and expression.
Depression
Depression is common later in adulthood. Although , such a mood disorder can certainly be a result of the negative social impact of schizophrenia, some experts believe that depression is part of the disease process itself.
Effect on Social Status
Studies indicate that after 20 to 30 years, half of schizophrenic patients are able to care for themselves, work, and participate socially. Support services and appropriate housing improve this outcome. Unsurprisingly, the decline in status, including the inability to earn a living, is less steep when there are more financial resources and fewer emotional disorders at the outset of symptoms. Also, on average, the later the onset of the disease, the milder the social impact. The long-term effects on work and relationships, however, are usually severe and difficult to repair, even if symptoms improve.
Effect on Intelligence
In one study, about half of patients experienced some decline in IQ (10 points or more), but intelligence scores remained the same in the other half. Experts believe that a decline in IQ reflects early nerve damage but that it is not an inevitable consequence of the disease process.
Suicide and Self-Destructive Behaviors
In spite of their sometimes frightening behavior, people with schizophrenia are no more likely to behave violently than are those in the general population. In fact, these patients are more apt to withdraw from others or to harm themselves.
Suicide. Between 20% and 50% of patients with schizophrenia attempt suicide and an estimated 9% to 13% of schizophrenics succeed.
The general risk for suicide is higher at certain times in the course of the disease:
The widespread use of antipsychotic drugs over the past decade does not appear to have had much effect on suicide rates. In fact, evidence suggests that the use of these agents as a way of reducing hospitalization time is increasing the incidence of suicide. Hopelessness, not delusions, appears to be the most important motive for suicide in these patients. In one study of patients who had attempted suicide, the most frequent reason given for an attempt was depression, and the second was the loss of an intimate partner. Cognitive impairment, which reduces the patient's ability to hold jobs and function normally, also seems to be a major factor in suicidal motivation.
Smoking and Other Addictions. A large majority of people with schizophrenia abuse nicotine, alcohol, and other substances. Substance abuse, in addition to its other adverse effects, increases non-compliance with antipsychotic drugs in the schizophrenic patient and may exacerbate symptoms.
Smoking is of special interest. According to a 2000 study, up to 88% of schizophrenic patients are nicotine dependent. Biologic and genetic factors may be partially responsible for the addiction in this particular group. Nicotine helps reduce psychotic symptoms and impulsivity, perhaps by inhibiting the activity of a protein called monoamine oxidase B (MAO-B), which is linked to improved mood and possibly to nerve protection. Smoking in schizophrenia, then, may be a form of self-medication.
Note: Although attempts to help schizophrenic patients quit smoking usually fail, those taking atypical medications have a better chance of quitting successfully than those taking typical medications. The use of bupropion and therapeutic administration of nicotine may also help. (For further information, see the Well-Connected report, Smoking).
Effect on Children
A 2001 study reported that children of women with schizophrenia have a significantly higher risk for stillbirth or infant death. This is most likely due, however, to their higher risk for other factors that can contribute to infancy mortality rates, such as smoking, medications, or substance abuse.
Lack of Social and Government Support
In the 1970s, tens of thousands of patients were put on antipsychotic agents and released from institutions into the community, a concept called deinstitutionalization. In spite of these attempts to reduce mental hospital costs, schizophrenia still accounts for 40% of all long-term hospitalization days. More than half of patients with schizophrenia requires public assistance within a year of their reentry into the community. And using drugs alone has done nothing to reduce the high suicide rates among this patient group.
WHAT WILL CONFIRM A DIAGNOSIS OF SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Symptoms Suggesting a Diagnosis
The physician will use one or more verbal screening tests to help determine whether a patient's symptoms meet the criteria for schizophrenia. Because no single symptom is specific to schizophrenia, a diagnosis may be made when one or more of the following conditions is present:
Ruling Out Other Conditions
The common hallmarks of schizophrenia are also symptoms that can occur in dozens of other psychologic and medical conditions, as well as with certain medications. Shared symptoms include delusions, hallucinations, disorganized and incoherent speech, a flat tone of voice, and bizarrely disorganized or catatonic behavior (such as lack of speech, muscular rigidity, and unresponsiveness).
Among the conditions that may resemble schizophrenia are the following:
Imaging Techniques
A number of brain imaging techniques are becoming useful in detecting changes in the brain structure that relate to specific sets of symptoms in schizophrenia. At this time such techniques are used only as research tools, although some experts believe they may be useful for identifying candidates for early treatment among high-risk young people with early warnings signs of schizophrenia and brain damage.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has become a particularly valuable tool for revealing parts of the brain inaccessible to other scanning methods. MRI does not use radiation, and it can show the brain from a number of different perspectives.
Other Imaging Techniques. Other imaging techniques are single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) and positron emission tomography (PET), which can provide information on blood flow and metabolism in the brain.
Investigative Tests
Research is ongoing to find simple tests that will detect schizophrenia accurately and early enough to initiate preventive measures. Some examples include the following:
WHAT ARE THE GENERAL GUIDELINES FOR TREATING SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Overall Guidelines
Integrated Approach. Schizophrenia is now officially categorized as a brain disease, not a psychologic disorder, and drug treatment is the primary therapy. Studies indicate, however, that an integrated approach is superior in preventing relapses compared to routine care (drugs plus monitoring and access to rehabilitation programs). In one study, this approach involved the following:
In the study, relapse rates were 33% in the integrated group and 67% in the group who received routine care. Unfortunately, such treatment is expensive. Research shows that more than half of individuals with schizophrenia does not even receive routine care. Increased cost cutting in mental health services is making the situation worse. African Americans, in particular, are less likely to receive effective treatment.
Early Treatment. The earlier schizophrenia is detected and treated, the better the outcome. Patients who receive antipsychotic drugs and other treatments during their first episode are hospitalized less frequently during the following five years and may require less time to control the symptoms than those who do not seek help as quickly. One study, in fact, found that when patients with very early signs of schizophrenia were given low-dose medication and therapy that they reduced their risk for full-blown schizophrenia by tenfold. In spite of strong evidence for the positive effects of early treatment, patients usually endure an average of 10 months of serious symptoms before they receive treatment.
Classes of Drugs Used for Schizophrenia
Most drugs that treat schizophrenia work by blocking receptors of the neurotransmitter dopamine, which is thought to play a major role in psychotic symptoms. Although they all have important benefits for schizophrenia, most drugs used for schizophrenia also pose a risk for side effects associated with reduced dopamine. The most disturbing and common side effects are those known as extrapyramidal symptoms, which involve the nerves and muscles controlling movement and coordination. [ See Box
Extrapyramidal Symptoms.]Choosing Between Atypical and Standard Antipsychotic Agents. Experts are debating whether older antipsychotics or the new atypicals should be used at the onset of symptoms. The debate includes some of the following issues:
Treating an Acute or Initial Phase
For the severe, active phase of schizophrenia, injections of an antipsychotic drug are typically given every few hours until the patient is calm. Antianxiety agents are also often administered at the same time. Injections of some of the newer atypical agents, such as olanzapine, may prove to be as effective as the older antipsychotics with significantly fewer severe side effects. (Of particular interest is a new oral solution of the atypical agent risperidone, which may prove to be a valuable alternative in the emergency room.) In any case, if possible, physicians prefer administering a drug orally or at least switching to an oral drug as soon as possible.
In patients who are being treated for the first time, improvement in psychotic symptoms may be evident within one or two days of treatment, although the full benefit of the drug usually becomes manifest over about six to eight weeks. Thought disturbances tend to abate more gradually.
Maintenance
To reduce the risk of relapse, many physicians recommend that drugs be given daily for at least one year. Atypical agents are increasingly being used as maintenance for those with new-onset psychosis, although the choice of the drug depends on many factors. Side effects and effectiveness vary from individual to individual, and some trial and error adjustments may be necessary when prescribing dosage amounts so that the benefits of treatment outweigh the side effects of the therapy. The drug effects must be monitored carefully by the physician.
Keeping patients on maintenance therapy, however, is very difficult and many patients stop their medicaton. Two 2000 studies suggested factors that might affect either positive or negative medication compliance. In one, patients least likely to adhere to their medication regimens had the following:
In the other 2000 study, patients were more likely to take their medications if they perceived their illness as severe and believed that the drugs would prevent future hospitalizations. It should be noted that neither of these studies indicated whether the medications used were standard antipsychotics or atypical agents. Adding psychotherapy, such as cognitive therapy, to the regimen may help reduce this rate.
Stopping Medications
According to a 2001 study, nearly all patients experience some relapse or worsening of symptoms within two years of stopping maintenance medication. However, in the same study they were closely monitored and medications were reinstated early enough so that only 13% required hospitalization.
Supportive Agents
Antidepressants and antianxiety agents may also play an important role in treating the patient with schizophrenia, particularly given the role of depression in the high rates of suicide among these patients.
General Guidelines for Psychologic Treatments
Experts generally agree that current treatment should offer both medical and psychological treatment to the patient. Cognitive-behavioral approaches are showing promise. Support to the family or other caregiver is also important for the long-term improvement of people with schizophrenia.
WHAT ARE THE SPECIFIC DRUG TREATMENTS FOR SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Atypical Drugs
A number of atypicals are either available or under investigation. Clozapine (Clozaril) was the first atypical antipsychotic. Newer agents include risperidone (Risperdal), olanzapine (Zyprexa), quetiapine (Seroquel), ziprasidone (Zeldox), and others. They appear to have fewer side effects than clozapine. Not all are available in the US.
Atypical agents have the following benefits:
It may take up to six months before they have an effect. In-depth comparative studies are needed to determine which specific agents are more effective and have fewer side effects than others. Some comparative studies are reported in the table below. [See Table
Comparing Atypical Agents.]The following are some severe side effects or complications that may occur in with most of these agents:
|
Comparing Atypical Agents |
||
|
|
Comparative Studies on Effectiveness |
Adverse Effects that May Differ from Other Atypicals |
|
Clozapine (Clozaril) |
Superior to risperidone for severe, chronic schizophrenia (2001 study). |
Agranulocytosis (1.3% with Clozapine). Potentially life-threatening reduction in white blood cells. Occurs within three months of taking clozapine. Higher risk in older women. Unlikely to develop after six months. Can be reversed if clozapine is withdrawn at once. |
|
Risperidone (Risperdal) |
Obtained greater reductions in severity of positive symptoms and depression and anxiety than olanzapine (2001 study). |
Less risk for weight gain than clozapine and possibly some other atypicals, such as olanzapine, but still can be a problem. In one study 12% gained weight. |
|
Olanzapine (Zyprexa) |
Fewer and shorter hospitalizations with the drug compared to risperidone (2001 study). |
May have higher risk for weight gain (27% in one study) and diabetes than other atypicals (except for clozapine). |
|
Quetiapine (Seroquel) |
Similar to older antipsychotics in treating positive and negative symptoms. May improve mental performance. May have benefits for elderly patients. |
Appears to have no effect on weight gain. |
|
Ziprasidone (Geodon) |
May improve negative as well as positive symptoms. |
Appears to have no significant risk for weight gain, high cholesterol levels, or diabetes. May, however, have some adverse effect on heart rate compared to other atypicals. |
|
Zotepine (Zoleptil), |
No clear difference from other atypicals. |
May have less risk for extrapyramidal side effects than some atypicals. |
|
Amisulpride (Solian). * |
This is a newer agent, sometimes referred to as a dopamine system stabilizer. It is more selective and is the only atypical to date for which studies report significant effects on negative symptoms as well as psychosis. It may also improve cognitive functioning. |
May have less risk for extrapyramidal and other side effects than some atypicals. |
|
*Other new dopamine stabilizers under investigation include aripiprazole (Abilitat) and iloperidone (Zomaril) |
||
Typical Antipsychotic (or Neuroleptic) Drugs
The standard neuroleptic drug used for schizophrenia is haloperidol (Haldol). Others include chlorpromazine (Thorazine), perphenazine (Trilafon), thioridazine (Mellaril), mesoridazine (Serentil), trifluoperazine (Stelazine), and fluphenazine (Prolixin). Studies have not shown any significant difference in benefits among these drugs. The beneficial impact of these drugs is greatest on psychotic symptoms, particularly hallucinations and delusions in the early and midterm stages of the disorder. They are not very successful in reducing negative symptoms. Because of their significant side effects, compliance is often very low. Depot therapy (long-lasting monthly injections, usually of haloperidol or fluphenazine) have been used with success in people who have difficulty complying with a daily regimen of these agents.
Side Effects of Neuroleptics. Neuroleptics can have adverse side effects related to many organs and systems in the body. The very name neuroleptic derives from the neurologic side effects that these drugs cause, which can be very severe. Side effects include the following:
The most disturbing and common side effects are those known as extrapyramidal symptoms, which involve the nerves and muscles controlling movement and coordination. In fact, a 1999 analysis reported that fewer than 12% of patients faithfully took these drugs over the course of a year, predominantly because of such adverse effects. [ See Box Extrapyramidal Side Effects.]
|
Extrapyramidal Symptoms Nearly every agent used to date for schizophrenia can cause extrapyramidal side effects to some degree. These side effects involve the nerves and muscles controlling movement and coordination.
Treatment of Extrapyramidal Side Effects. In general, if extrapyramidal side effects occur from neuroleptic drugs, the physician may first try to reduce the dosage or switch to an atypical drug. Other approaches to reduce these symptoms include the following:
|
Useful Supportive Drugs
Antidepressants. Antidepressants are recommended along with antipsychotics to alleviate the depression that is so common in people with schizophrenia. One study indicated that taking antidepressants may even help prevent relapse. In spite of their benefits, less than half of all patients are given these medications.
Anti-Anxiety Drugs. Benzodiazepines are drugs normally used to treat anxiety. They also have some modest effect on psychotic symptoms. They may be useful in the early stages of a psychotic relapse for preventing a full attack. They also are sometimes used to treat the restlessness and agitation that can occur with the use of neuroleptics. Severe side effects, including respiratory arrest, very low blood pressure, and loss of consciousness, have been reported in a few people taking antianxiety medication and clozapine but there is no evidence yet of a clear danger associated with the use of these two drugs. In any case, prolonged use of anti-anxiety drugs is generally not recommended in schizophrenia; withdrawal from these agents should be achieved gradually.
Lithium. Lithium, ordinarily used for bipolar disorder, is useful for some schizophrenic patients. It appears to help those with fewer negative symptoms and without a family history of schizophrenia. However, there are no reliable criteria to predict who will benefit.
Antiepileptic Drugs. Drugs ordinarily prescribed for epilepsy, such as carbamazepine (Tegretol), gabapentin (Neurontin), lamotrigine (Lamictal), or others, are occasionally used in combination with neuroleptics or atypical agents for patients who do not respond to standard drugs.
Investigative Therapies for Improving Cognitive Function
Experts are investigating agents to be used along with antipsychotics or atypicals for improving mental function. Developing such agents would be an important advance in this disease, particularly as some research suggests that cognitive disturbances play a major role in suicide motivation. The agents being investigated include:
Alternative Treatments
Alternative remedies are often used for chronic illnesses. It should be strongly noted that not all are safe and their effectiveness, if any, cannot be guaranteed. [ See Box
Warnings on Alternative and So-Called Natural Remedies.]|
Warnings on Alternative and So-Called Natural Remedies It should be strongly noted that alternative or natural remedies are not regulated and their quality is not publicly controlled. In addition, any substance that can affect the body's chemistry can, like any drug, produce side effects that may be harmful. Even if studies report positive benefits from herbal remedies, the compounds used in such studies are, in most cases, not what are being marketed to the public. The Food and Drug Administration has a program called MEDWATCH for people to report adverse reactions to untested substances, such as herbal remedies and vitamins (call 800-332-1088). |
WHAT ARE PSYCHOLOGICAL THERAPIES FOR SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Between one-fifth and one-third of all patients with schizophrenia do not respond adequately to drug treatment. And, many patients who have been successfully treated with medications experience the "awakenings" phenomena, which are painful reactions that are manifested as inner emotions and the recognition of real losses. The effects of the disease, in any case, are profoundly emotional.
Cognitive-Behavioral and Other Psychosocial Therapies
The use of cognitive-behavioral method is showing particular promise for improvement in both positive and negative symptoms in some patients, and the benefits may persist after treatment has stopped. This approach attempts to strengthen the patient's capacity for normal thinking using mental exercises and self-observation. Patients with schizophrenia are taught to critically analyze hallucinations and examine underlying beliefs in them.
In a 2000 study, for example, patients underwent the following process:
Family and Outside Support Structures
Positive social interaction is extremely important for people with schizophrenia and may help reduce symptoms, including the number of delusional moments.
Family Support. It is deeply painful for anyone to interact with a loved one whose behavior is determined by a mysterious internal mechanism that has gone awry. Given support and direction, however, families or other caregivers can be very helpful in a number of ways:
Unfortunately, the family's own mental health is often threatened and they need help almost as much as the patient does. Numerous studies have shown that schizophrenic patients do worse in families who are too emotional, hostile, critical, or even overly involved. The problem is an emotional loop:
Studies indicate that once the patient receives appropriate treatment and support, the family's over-emotional state also recedes. And, two studies reported that when families received help for themselves (group support or cognitive therapy) the relapse rates for the related patients were significantly lower than for patients whose families did not seek help. For example, when families received cognitive therapy, the patient relapse rate was 37% versus 72% in the group without family support. Still, fewer than 10% of families of patients with schizophrenia receive the support and education needed not only for the patient but also for themselves. [ See Where Else Can Someone Get Help For Schizophrenia?, below.]
Community Treatment Programs. Community treatment programs, in which a team of professional caregivers provides treatment and support for patients in their homes, is highly beneficial and cost effective (compared to frequent hospitalization). At this time, however, only between 2% and 10% of patients now participate in such programs.
Vocational Rehabilitation. Paid work is very important in the health of the patient. One study reported that after one year, 40% of workers with schizophrenia who were paid for their labor reported much improvement in all symptoms and 50% reported much improvement in positive symptoms. Those who were not paid for their work did considerably less well. (The arts and crafts activities that are often used to enhance self-esteem in rehabilitation programs offer few real benefits to the patient.) Unfortunately, at this time, less than a quarter of patients with schizophrenia are in programs that assist them in finding and keeping jobs, and up to 90% of patients with severe mental problems are unemployed.
WHAT PROCEDURES ARE USED TO TREAT SCHIZOPHRENIA?
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), often called shock treatment, has received bad press since it was introduced in the 1940s. However, refined techniques have revived its use, particularly for those with severe depression. Imaging studies have not found that current ECT techniques cause any damage to the brain's structure, and some physicians feel it is safer than drug therapy. A major 2000 analysis reported that ECT may provide some short-term relief, but it does not appear to be equal in effectiveness to drug therapies. In spite of 50 years of use, however, research on ECT and schizophrenia is limited. In one 2000 Japanese study, for example, nearly 60% of patients with schizophrenia went into remission after treatment with ECT. The US, however, may limit the output charge to the extent that it may not be as effective. (Higher currents may increase the risk for seizures.)
Magnetic Stimulation
Some research suggests that auditory hallucinations may be due to inappropriate activation of the brain circuitry responsible for speech processing. With this in mind, some investigators are testing magnetic stimulation of the scalp in the area above and behind the left ear (which corresponds to the speech processing region). In one early study, between 60% and 70% of patients receiving this therapy experienced significant reductions in hearing voices by 50% or more. Further research is underway. Other attempts at magnetic stimulation have not been successful.
WHERE ELSE CAN SOMEONE GET HELP FOR SCHIZOPHRENIA?
National Institute of Mental Health, 6001 Executive Blvd., Rm 8184, MSC 9663, Bethesda, MD 20892-9663. Call (301-443-4513 ) or call (301-443-4279 ) from a fax machine to receive a directory of faxed reports on mental health problems. On the Internet at (
http://www.nimh.nih.gov/)Recent Literature
Review Date: March 2002
This Report Reviewed by:
Harvey Simon, MD, Editor-in-Chief, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Theodore A. Stern, MD, Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School; Psychiatrist and Chief, Psychiatric Consultation Service, Massachusetts General Hospital
ABOUT WELL-CONNECTED
Well-Connected reports are written and updated by experienced medical writers and reviewed and edited by the in-house editors and a board of physicians who have faculty positions at Harvard Medical School and Massachusetts General Hospital. Neither Harvard Medical School nor Massachusetts General Hospital, as institutions, review or endorse their content. The reports are distinguished from other information sources available to patients and health care consumers by their quality, detail of information, and currency. These reports are not intended as a substitute for medical professional help or advice but are to be used only as an aid in understanding current medical knowledge. A physician should always be consulted for any health problem or medical condition. The reports may not be copied without the express permission of the publisher.
Board of Editors
Harvey Simon, MD, Editor-in-Chief, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Stephen A. Cannistra, MD, Oncology, Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School; Director, Gynecologic Medical Oncology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
John E. Godine, MD, PhD, Metabolism, Harvard Medical School; Associate Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Edwin Huang, MD, Gynecology, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Massachusetts General Hospital
Daniel Heller, MD, Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School; Associate Pediatrician, Massachusetts General Hospital; Active Staff, Children's Hospital
Paul C. Shellito, MD, Surgery, Harvard Medical School; Associate Visiting Surgeon, Massachusetts General Hospital
Theodore A. Stern, MD, Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School; Psychiatrist and Chief, Psychiatric Consultation Service, Massachusetts General Hospital
Nidus Information Services
Cynthia Chevins, Publisher
Bruce Carlson, Business Development Manager
Carol Peckham, Editorial Director
Sherry Knecht, Update Editor
Nidus Information Services, Inc., 41 East 11th Street, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10003 or email